K.W. v. Armstrong

  • Filed: 01/18/2012
  • Status: Victory!
  • Court: United States District Court for the District of Idaho
  • Latest Update: Jan 18, 2012
Lawsuit plaintiff Christie Mathwig sitting in a wheel chair with her dog on her lap in her house

Giving adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities in Idaho a fair chance.

Stay up to date with this case and the Idaho Medicaid program for adults with developemental disabilities via the Our Health and Welfare Facebook page.

The ACLU of Idaho represents adults with developmental disabilities throughout the state in a case called K.W. v. Armstrong. With functional ages of 8-years-old and below, these Idahoans rely on Medicaid assistance to live in their communities and with their families, rather than in costly institutional settings. When the State of Idaho drastically cut their assistance to dangerously low levels, the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare claimed that the reasons for the cuts were “trade secrets” and refused to disclose the formula it used to calculate the reductions. We obtained an injunction stopping the cuts and requiring the State to make its Medicaid formulas public for all Idaho residents to review, which the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld in 2015. In March 2016, Idaho’s federal district court struck down the Department’s formula and ordered to State to develop comprehensive plans to bring its system up to constitutional muster. A class action settlement was submitted to the Court in September 2016, and is now awaiting Court approval. If approved, the settlement will require the Department of Health and Welfare to develop a new system, with input and oversight by the ACLU of Idaho and participants and their families throughout the state.

Case Number:
1:12-cv-00022-BLW
Judge:
B. Lynn Winmill
Attorney(s):
Ritchie Eppink, Molly Kafka, James Piotrowski, Marty Durand
Pro Bono Firm:
Herzfeld & Piotrowski, LLP

Federal Court Rules Against Idaho Department of Health and Welfare in Medicaid Classs Action

Ruling Mandates Important Protections for Due Process Rights of Idahoans with Developmental DisabilitiesBOISE, Idaho – Idaho’s Chief Federal Judge B. Lynn Winmill has ordered the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare to develop substantial additional safeguards to protect Idaho Medicaid participants. The decision comes as the latest ACLU of Idaho victory in the K.W. v. Armstrong class action. The lawsuit, over Idaho’s Medicaid programs for adults with developmental disabilities, contended that the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare cut Medicaid participants’ assistance without adequate notification or procedural protections. The federal court agreed this week, holding that the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare “arbitrarily deprives participants of their property rights and hence violates due process.”

Idaho Department of Health and Welfare logo

ACLU Seeks Statewide Due Process Protections for Adults with Developmental Disabilities

Afte

Placeholder image

Related News & Podcasts

News & Commentary
Mar 30, 2016
Idaho Department of Health and Welfare logo

Federal Court Rules Against Idaho Department of Health and Welfare in Medicaid Classs Action

Ruling Mandates Important Protections for Due Process Rights of Idahoans with Developmental DisabilitiesBOISE, Idaho – Idaho’s Chief Federal Judge B. Lynn Winmill has ordered the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare to develop substantial additional safeguards to protect Idaho Medicaid participants. The decision comes as the latest ACLU of Idaho victory in the K.W. v. Armstrong class action. The lawsuit, over Idaho’s Medicaid programs for adults with developmental disabilities, contended that the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare cut Medicaid participants’ assistance without adequate notification or procedural protections. The federal court agreed this week, holding that the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare “arbitrarily deprives participants of their property rights and hence violates due process.”
News & Commentary
May 31, 2013
Placeholder image

ACLU Seeks Statewide Due Process Protections for Adults with Developmental Disabilities

Afte