ALDF v. Wasden

  • Filed: 03/17/2014
  • Status: Victory!
  • Court: Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
  • Latest Update: Mar 17, 2014
A group of cows in a pasture

Protecting Idaho’s press, animals, and food sources.

Over opposition from all across Idaho and beyond, the Idaho legislature in 2014 passed an “Ag Gag” law, gagging speech that is critical of industrial agriculture. Under this law, journalists, workers, activists, and members of the public could have been convicted for documenting animal cruelty, life-threatening worker safety violations, or threats to public health in our food supply. Promptly after the legislature passed the law, though, the ACLU of Idaho joined with a broad coalition, including the Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF), People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), the Center for Food Safety, Farm Sanctuary, Western Watersheds Project, the Idaho Hispanic Caucus, and journalist Will Potter to challenge the law.

In August 2015, we won a federal court ruling that the law is unconstitutional because it violates both free speech and equal protection guarantees. The State of Idaho appealed that ruling and in January 2018 the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed most of that ruling, striking down the core components of Idaho's Ag Gag statute.

Case Number:
15-35960
Attorney(s):
Richard Eppink, Justin Marceau, Matthew Liebman, Alan Chen, Matthew Strugar, Leslie Brueckner, Paige Tomaselli, Maria Andrade
Pro Bono Firm:
Andrade Legal

ACLU Idaho and Coalition Files Lawsuit Over Controversial "Ag Gag" Law

Constitutional Challenge Made to State’s Attempt to Silence Factory Farm Whistle-Blowers

Ag-Gag.jpg

Idaho “Ag-Gag” Law Ruled Unconstitutional in Federal Court

Victory for Animals: District Court Rules Anti-Whistleblower Law Violates U.S. Constitution

A group of cows in a pasture

The First Stop in Challenging Idaho's Ag-gag Law

Idah

ag-gag-500x280-v01.jpg

Related News & Podcasts

News & Commentary
Mar 17, 2014
Ag-Gag.jpg

ACLU Idaho and Coalition Files Lawsuit Over Controversial "Ag Gag" Law

Constitutional Challenge Made to State’s Attempt to Silence Factory Farm Whistle-Blowers
News & Commentary
Aug 03, 2015
A group of cows in a pasture

Idaho “Ag-Gag” Law Ruled Unconstitutional in Federal Court

Victory for Animals: District Court Rules Anti-Whistleblower Law Violates U.S. Constitution
News & Commentary
Jul 07, 2014
ag-gag-500x280-v01.jpg

The First Stop in Challenging Idaho's Ag-gag Law

Idah

Related Content

Know Your Rights
Jul 10, 2025
A person holding a megaphone with a raised fist at a protest rally.
  • LGBTQ Justice|
  • +3 Issues

Your Rights Under the First Amendment

This amendment gives us freedoms that are the bedrock of democracy.
Resource
Placeholder image

Archived Cases