Public Defense Reform

Idahoans’ constitutional right to an attorney continues to be undermined, despite our decade-long fight for equal access to legal counsel.

Image of a generic, empty courtroom with wood tones.

What you need to know

1 in 3 Idahoans can’t afford a private attorney.

So they must rely on public defenders.

Idaho families are suffering.

Every day, Idahoans are being denied their constitutional right to adequate legal counsel.

Idaho’s public defense system is defective.

The ACLU is working to fix it.

The ACLU, the ACLU of Idaho, and the global law firm Hogan Lovells filed a lawsuit against the State of Idaho in 2015 on behalf of tens of thousands of Idahoans who cannot afford a private attorney. Our class action lawsuit, known as Tucker v. State of Idaho, demands an end to Idaho’s public defense system crisis.

A decade later, litigation continues.

Read below to learn the latest in public defense, our ongoing work to protect every Idahoans’ Sixth Amendment right to legal representation, and our persistent efforts to hold the State accountable for violations of this fundamental right.

What’s New in Public Defense?

The State of Idaho assumed responsibility for delivering all public defense services on October 1, 2024; previously, public defense was managed at the county level. Idaho’s new statewide system has so far failed to provide the most basic and fundamental services required of public defense. The state’s failure directly affects tens of thousands of Idahoans in the certified class of plaintiffs.

The persistent, uneven, and statewide issues with Idaho’s public defense system prompted our team to file an emergency motion in December of 2024 in the Idaho Supreme Court. The filing details significant flaws in the state’s public defense system. These flaws, while specific to the new Office of the State Public Defender (SPD), are firmly rooted in the ACLU of Idaho’s decade-long legal challenge to Idaho’s public defense system (Tucker v. State).

Lawmakers have, in recent years, passed legislation related to public defense. Unfortunately, these efforts have failed to address significant and persistent defects in Idaho’s public defense system. Staffing shortages and case management issues continue to contribute to widespread delays in (or total absence of) adequate legal representation for Idahoans.

Absent meaningful reform, our legal advocacy continues.

Follow us on socials or check this page to stay updated on Tucker and public defense in Idaho.

The Latest


Resource
A worn American flag is covered by barb wire outside a prison

2025 Legislative Session: Criminal Justice

In 2025, Idaho lawmakers passed a half dozen laws that will further burden our courts, prisons, and jails.
Press Release
Wooden gavel

ACLU files emergency motion asking court to intervene in State Public Defender disaster

The ACLU filed an emergency motion with the Idaho Supreme Court in the Tucker v. State of Idaho class action.
Press Release
Wooden gavel

Long-running Class Action Over Idaho’s Public Defense Crisis Heads to Idaho Supreme Court for Third Time

The American Civil Liberties Union of Idaho lawsuit challenging the constitutional adequacy of Idaho’s provision of public defense is headed to the Idaho Supreme Court for the third time since 2016.
Press Release
Wooden gavel

Idaho Supreme Court Again Sides with ACLU in Public Defense Lawsuit

Decision paves the way for structural changes to Idaho’s public defense system.

Cases, Campaigns & Legislation


Legislation
Jan 26, 2021

2021 – Public Defense Rules

The ACLU of Idaho provided comment to the PDC on proposed rules in Oct. of 2020. None of those recommendations were incorporated into the rules that are now pending before the Idaho Legislature. Currently, those rules fail to adequately address Idaho’s failing public defense system.
Status: Pending
Position: Oppose Unless Amended
Legislation
Feb 4, 2019

2019 — SJR 102 Marsy’s Law

Status: Won: Failed to Pass Senate
Position: Oppose
Legislation
Jan 22, 2019

2019 — Public Defense Rules: Workload Standards

Status: Accepted
Position: Oppose
Legislation
Feb 12, 2018

2018- SJR 104 Constitutional Amendment on Bail

Status: Introduced
Position: Oppose